What a difference a committee assignment makes
Nov 20, 2026
Get an insider’s look into what’s happening in and around the halls of power with expert reporting, analysis and insight from the editors and reporters of Montana Free Press. Sign up to get the free Capitolized newsletter delivered to your inbox every Thursday.
Sign up
Infighting among Senate Republicans was a near-daily occurrence during the 2025 legislative session, and many legislators and onlookers left that session wondering if the tenor would be similar in 2027.
A 45-minute Wednesday morning meeting of the Senate’s redundantly named Committee on Committees gave us some clues about what to expect come Jan. 4, when lawmakers gavel in for the 2027 session.
The Committee on Committees is a panel composed entirely of members of the majority party (Republicans in this case) that makes legislative committee assignments. Committee assignments are crucial to which policies get passed, since a bill typically has to be approved by at least two committees before it can become law.
It was committee assignments that initially sparked tensions among Republicans when centrist conservatives strategically aligned with Democrats to reshuffle a slew of assignments on the session’s first day in 2025. From that first day until the end of the session, those centrists repeatedly joined with Democrats on key votes, and the Republican caucus was never able to reconcile its differences.
During Wednesday’s meeting, the two centrist members of the six-member committee offered multiple amendments aimed at assigning more of their ideological allies to legislative committees. All of those attempts were rebuffed by the four hardline members of the committee.
At the center of debate on Wednesday were the Senate Finance and Claims Committee assignments. Finance and Claims is one of the Legislature’s most powerful committees. It reviews bills that carry a price tag, and plays a key role in amending the state budget.
The Committee on Committees assigned eight Democrats and 12 Republicans to Finance and Claims, with only two of those Republicans being members of the Solutions Caucus, the informally organized group of relatively centrist Republicans. If those two Republicans were to join with Democrats against party-line Republicans on key votes, the committee would be tied. A tie vote stalls a bill in committee.
Solutions Caucus member Sen.-elect David Bedey, R-Hamilton, tried to amend two other centrist Republicans onto Finance and Claims, but was voted down.
Bedey argued that more moderates should hold seats on Finance and Claims because, in his view, most Montanans hold moderate political views.
Committee on Committees Chairman Sen. Carl Glimm, R-Kila, said he felt the committee had been accommodating in its assignments, but said he and other hardliners were not going to just lie down and cede power to Republican moderates with whom they’re often at odds.
Sen. Carl Glimm, R-Kila, speaking at a press conference on the last day of the 69th Legislature on April 30, 2025. Credit: Mara Silvers/MTFP Credit: Mara Silvers / MTFP
“I think we’ve been extremely fair, but we aren’t willing to give them absolutely everything,” Glimm said.
Both Bedey and his moderate ally on the Committee on Committees, Sen. Josh Kassmier, R-Fort Benton, told Capitolized following the meeting that attempting to amend committee assignments on the Senate floor on the first day of the session with the help of Democrats — as happened in 2025 — is an option they’re considering.
“If they’re willing to blow it all up for a couple seats up on Finance and Claims, they’re gonna set us up for a pretty contentious session,” Glimm told Capitolized after Wednesday’s meeting.
—Victoria Eavis
ONE CANDIDATE, TWO PARTIES?
There was a time in Montana politics when voters could support a third party without casting their vote for a third-party candidate.
Montana used to allow two different political parties to nominate the same candidate. In the general election, that candidate could appear twice on the ballot, once under each party label. Voters could choose which party line to vote on, and the votes from each party line were combined into the candidate’s total.
The practice is called fusion voting. Supporters are now suing to resurrect it.
More than a century ago, fusion voting played a significant role in Montana elections, according to a lawsuit filed in October challenging the state’s ban on the practice.
Who remembers the fusion wave that ushered William Y. Pemberton onto the state Supreme Court in 1892? Or the fusion vote that elected Montana’s governor in 1904? Attorney Constance Van Kley does. Her court filings present a detailed history of fusion voting in Montana and its prohibition in 1907.
The complaint was filed by the Montana Libertarian Party and the newly formed Make Ends Meet Party, along with voters and current and former candidates, including independent U.S. House candidate Michael Eisenhauer. Eisenhauer was a candidate for Montana’s 2nd Congressional District this year.
Van Kley represents Make Ends Meet. Former Republican legislator Matthew Monforton is the attorney representing the Libertarians.
The parties allege that Republicans, after gaining control of the Legislature, passed the ban in 1907 and overrode a veto from then-Gov. Joseph Toole, who had been elected as a fusion candidate.
The lawsuit, filed against Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen, argues that the fusion voting ban violates state constitutional protections for speech and association, equal protection and the right of suffrage. The plaintiffs ask the court to strike down two Montana statutes that block fusion voting.
The plaintiffs’ goal is to get fusion voting revived for the 2028 general election.
The lawsuit addresses a persistent challenge for third parties: the spoiler effect. A voter might like a third party but fear that voting for its candidate could deliver a win to the major-party candidate the voter likes least.
The Make Ends Meet Party says in the lawsuit that it wants the ability to endorse major-party candidates who share its focus on affordability. The Montana Libertarian Party says it would continue running its own candidates, but also would consider cross-nominating major-party candidates when their positions align.
Van Kley told Capitolized that a fusion option would allow voters to say two things with the same vote: This is my candidate, and this is the party I want the candidate to listen to.
—Tom Lutey
PROGRAMMING NOTE
We’ll be skipping next week’s Capitolized in deference to the Thanksgiving holiday. Capitolized will be back in your inbox on Thursday, Dec. 3
The post What a difference a committee assignment makes appeared first on Montana Free Press.
...read more
read less