Booker's recordbreaking speech proves Democrats are stuck in the past
Apr 04, 2025
In our era of lightning-fast news cycles, Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.) has claimed a peculiar distinction: surpassing South Carolina Sen. Strom Thurmond's notorious 24-hour civil rights filibuster to deliver the longest speech in Senate history.
This feat, while impressive in its physical
endurance, inadvertently illustrates the fundamental disconnect between Democratic messaging strategy and today's media reality.
The contrast is striking. While Booker committed to a day-long monologue, the Trump administration has perfected Steve Bannon's "flood the zone" approach to media dominance. This strategy ensures a constant stream of headlines, controversies and policy shifts, each arriving before the previous can fully register in public consciousness. Just as one story gains traction, another supplants it, creating an environment where opponents remain perpetually reactive rather than proactive.
This Republican media mastery reflects a sophisticated understanding of our fractured attention economy. Trump, regardless of one's opinion of him, demonstrates an intuitive grasp of narrative control through this relentless cadence of headlines. The approach prevents any single controversy from gaining critical mass while ensuring his administration retains the initiative in shaping public discourse.
Democrats, meanwhile, cling to tactics better suited to an earlier political era. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) recently acknowledged this weakness when he admitted to New York Times’s Lulu Garcia-Navarro that the Democrats “neglected how the social media has become so much more important” — a stunning confession of digital mishap from one of the party's most powerful figures.
According to Schumer, Senate Democrats put Booker and Sen. Tina Smith (D-Minn.) in charge of social. That is some irony, because Booker's marathon speech demonstrated the outdated approach of Democrats — a strategy from when extended floor speeches might dominate news coverage for days. In today's digital media landscape, even the most impassioned oratory becomes yesterday's news before the speaker has returned to their office.
The sole exception to this Democratic digital deficit is Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.), whose social media fluency stands in stark contrast to her party's leadership. With her youth, charisma and political savvy, Ocasio-Cortez has mastered the modern communication landscape that eludes her colleagues. She is now frequently discussed as not only the heir apparent to Sen. Bernie Sanders' (I-Vt.) progressive movement but as a potential presidential contender for 2028 — recognition that, while certainly premature, acknowledges her singular ability to connect with voters through contemporary channels.
Yet Ocasio-Cortez's exception proves the rule. By tomorrow, voters won't be discussing Booker's record-setting performance — they'll be responding to whatever new headline has captured the news cycle. Meanwhile, Democratic leadership continues to mistake endurance for effectiveness, length for impact.
This failure to adapt to contemporary political communication represents a troubling blind spot for Democratic leadership. Their continued reliance on traditional tactics against opponents who have rewritten the rulebook suggests a fundamental misunderstanding of how political narratives now form and dissipate.
For Republicans watching this disconnect, there's certainly strategic advantage in seeing opponents adhere to an obsolete playbook. If Democrats persist in believing that extended speeches can generate sustained momentum in our hyperactive media environment, their path to electoral relevance becomes increasingly narrow.
Rather than expend political oxygen — quite literally — on tactics ill-suited to today's information ecosystem, Democrats would be better served examining why their messaging struggles to penetrate the noise. Until they acknowledge that the media landscape has fundamentally changed, they will continue trailing behind as Republicans set the agenda through their mastery of the perpetual news cycle.
Kurt Davis Jr. is a Millennium Fellow at the Atlantic Council and a member of the Council on Foreign Relations. He is also an advisor to private, public and state-owned companies and their boards as well as creditors across the globe on a range of transactions. ...read more read less