California woman facing murder charge after man dies in paid fetish encounter
Mar 18, 2025
ESCONDIDO, Calif. (FOX 5/KUSI) — A 31-year-old woman has been charged with second-degree murder in connection to the 2023 death of an Escondido man during a paid sexual fetish encounter, which was allegedly filmed for her OnlyFans account.
Michaela Rylaarsdam, a San Bernardino County resident,
was arrested by Escondido police last month following a months-long investigation into the fatal encounter between her and 56-year-old Michael Dale.
According to the affidavit attached to the arrest warrant for Rylaarsdam, Dale suffocated to death while a bag was placed over his head and secured with duct tape for at least eight minutes during their interaction.
‘Dangerous’ drug trafficking ring shut down in Southern California
Dale had first reached out to Rylaarsdam in March 2023 after discovering her advertisement on an escort service website. The two exchanged a number of text messages and phone calls before she agreed to come to his Escondido home on April 17 of that year.
During these conversations, Escondido police said Dale made a series of requests to the then-29-year-old to engage in BDSM — an umbrella term to describe sexual practices like bondage, discipline, dominance, sadism and submission.
According to the affidavit, Dale asked her to "wrap him up in saran wrap like a mummy," glue a pair of women's boots onto his feet and pour adhesive onto his eyes to seal them shut, among other acts.
Over the course of their roughly four-hour in-person encounter at his home, Rylaarsdam appeared to have carried out some of these requests, police said, including wrapping his legs in saran wrap and gluing a pair of boots onto his feet.
According to the affidavit, Dale had been noticeably intoxicated when the two began engaging in these activities shortly after she arrived at the house at 6 p.m.
Escondido police and fire personnel were called to the scene around 10:10 p.m. after Rylaarsdam called 9-1-1 to report that Dale became unresponsive.
Upon arrival, officers found Rylaarsdam attempting CPR on Dale. Paramedics then took over and transported him to Palomar Hospital for further treatment. Dale was declared brain-dead the following day and taken off life support several days later.
While on the scene, Rylaarsdam allowed police to review and download files on her phone. The affidavit said police were able to confirm some of the requests Dale made, including using saran wrap to bind his legs and pouring glue on his eyes.
Multiple Teslas found vandalized at Encinitas dealership
Rylaarsdam also told police it was her first time engaging in fetish behavior and she had recorded some of the interactions to use as "content" for her OnlyFans page.
In these videos, police said Dale could be seen lying unresponsive with the bag over his head, his wrists and legs bound, while Rylaarsdam performed a sex act next to him. However, she denied placing and securing the bag over his head, according to the affidavit.
The 31-year-old pleaded not guilty to one charge of second-degree murder in the case and is being held without bail in a San Diego County jail. She is set to appear in court again next week for a readiness hearing. ...read more read less